Rhode Island Court Allows Malpractice Plaintiff to Sue Reinsurers Directly Following Hospital, Insurer Bankruptcies

November 20, 2026 by matray

A Rhode Island Superior Court judge ruled that a medical malpractice plaintiff may pursue claims directly against four reinsurance companies after both the defendant hospital and its primary liability insurer filed for bankruptcy, a decision that could have significant implications for reinsurers providing medical professional liability coverage in the state. 

In a recent decision, Superior Court Justice Richard Licht denied motions to dismiss filed by The Medical Protective Co., Berkshire Hathaway Specialty Insurance Co., Berkley Insurance Co. and Continental Casualty Co., finding that Rhode Island’ s insurance statutes permit direct actions against reinsurers under the circumstances presented. 

The ruling in Paone v. Prospect Chartercare SJHSRI LLC, No. PC-2023-01104, addresses whether reinsurers can be treated as liability insurers under Rhode Island’ s direct-action statute when both the alleged tortfeasor and its primary insurer are bankrupt.   

Russell Paone filed the underlying lawsuit in March 2023, individually and on behalf of the beneficiaries of the estate of Olivia Morgan Paone, against Prospect Chartercare SJHSRI LLC, doing business as Fatima Hospital, R.I. Ear, Nose and Throat Physicians Inc., and Martin Papazian, MD. 

Prospect filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in January 2025. Paone subsequently amended his complaint in January 2026 to substitute several insurance companies for the hospital under Rhode Island General Laws Section 27-7-2.4, which allows injured parties to sue an alleged tortfeasor’ s liability insurer directly when the tortfeasor files for bankruptcy. 

Connecticut Healthcare Insurance Co. (CHIC), one of Prospect’ s insurers, also filed for bankruptcy in May 2026. 

The four reinsurers argued that they could not be sued directly because their facultative reinsurance agreements with CHIC were indemnity contracts rather than liability insurance policies. Under those agreements, the reinsurers were obligated to reimburse CHIC for covered losses, subject to applicable retention limits, rather than make payments directly to injured parties. 

The contracts also contained insolvency provisions directing payments to CHIC or its receiver, liquidator or statutory successor in the event of insolvency. 

Licht acknowledged that the agreements were indemnity contracts but rejected the argument that this distinction excluded the reinsurers from Rhode Island’ s direct-action provisions. 

The judge examined Section 27-7-1, which requires policies insuring against liability for personal injuries, as well as policies indemnifying parties for such liability, to provide for direct liability to injured claimants. 

Licht traced the statute’ s language to a 1936 legislative amendment that expanded its application to indemnity policies following a federal court decision that had excluded such coverage. 

Because CHIC insured Prospect against personal injury liability and the reinsurers indemnified CHIC for covered losses exceeding applicable retention limits, Licht concluded that the reinsurance agreements were subject to the statute. 

The court further determined that contractual provisions limiting payment exclusively to CHIC or its bankruptcy representative were unenforceable under Section 27-7-3, which voids insurance policy provisions inconsistent with Rhode Island law. 

Reading the state’ s insurance statutes together, Licht concluded that when both an alleged tortfeasor and its liability insurer file for bankruptcy, a reinsurer indemnifying the bankrupt insurer qualifies as a liability insurer for purposes of the direct-action statute. 

The court also relied on the 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals’ 2011 decision in Rosciti v. Insurance Co. of Pennsylvania, which held that an excess insurer could not invoke a retained-limit provision to avoid liability solely because its insured had entered bankruptcy. 

Licht reasoned that requiring Paone to pursue recovery through CHIC’ s bankruptcy proceedings would undermine the legislative purpose of preserving compensation for injured parties. 

Under that scenario, Paone would have to seek relief from the bankruptcy stay, obtain a judgment against CHIC and then compete with other unsecured creditors for any recovery, even if the reinsurers ultimately indemnified CHIC. 

The court emphasized, however, that allowing a direct action does not expand the reinsurers’ contractual coverage obligations or require them to pay beyond applicable policy limits or below retained limits. 

The decision potentially expands direct litigation exposure for medical professional liability reinsurers operating under policies subject to Rhode Island law, particularly when both a healthcare provider and its primary insurer become insolvent. 

Although reinsurance traditionally creates a contractual relationship between the reinsurer and the ceding insurer, the ruling establishes that this distinction does not necessarily shield reinsurers from direct claims by injured parties under Rhode Island’ s statutory framework. 

The decision also raises questions about the enforceability of standard reinsurance insolvency clauses that restrict payment to a ceding insurer or its bankruptcy representative. Under the court’ s interpretation, such provisions cannot defeat statutory rights granted to injured claimants. 

For reinsurers, the ruling could also carry defense-cost implications. Although the court preserved contractual limits on indemnity obligations, it cited federal precedent recognizing that direct-action litigation may impose defense expenses beyond those originally anticipated. 

The decision is limited to the circumstances addressed by the court, including the bankruptcy of both the alleged tortfeasor and its primary insurer. It does not establish a general right to sue reinsurers directly in all medical liability cases. 

The ruling also does not determine whether malpractice occurred or whether the reinsurers ultimately owe damages. It allows Paone’s claims against the four reinsurers to proceed. 

The court denied the reinsurers’ motions to dismiss and directed counsel to submit an appropriate order. 

Posted in MPL company news, Significant court decisions | Leave a comment

«

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *