Mississippi Court Upholds Hospital Defense in Vicarious Liability Case
November 19, 2026
byThe Mississippi Court of Appeals upheld summary judgment for a hospital in a wrongful death malpractice lawsuit, ruling that the plaintiffs failed to establish
liability for the actions of independent contractors or prove negligence by hospital employees. The court found that the plaintiffs failed to rebut evidence that five of seven medical providers were independent contractors and that their expert did not identify any hospital employee who breached the standard of care.
Case: Hays v. Singing River Health System. No. 2025-CA-00544-COA,
Facts: In 2017, 67-year-old Curtis Hays was transferred from Biloxi Regional Medical Center to Singing River Health System’s Emergency Department. Hays had a prior history of high blood pressure, coronary artery disease, and an irregular heartbeat requiring an implanted defibrillator. He was transferred because of a suspected heart attack.
Within 30 minutes of his arrival, medical providers at Singing River performed a cardiac catheterization on Hays. The medical providers later removed a blood clot lodged in his right artery and performed angioplasty.
Despite the surgery, Hays continued to experience a decline in his heart’s output. Additional testing showed advanced congestive heart failure.
Dr. Michael Cunningham then inserted an intra-aortic balloon pump to alleviate the workload on Hays’ heart.
After the pump was placed, Hays was admitted to the intensive care unit where nurses Tangela Burkes and Cheryl Longfellow assisted in his treatment and recovery.
Cunningham set the balloon pump to inflate and deflate in sync with each heartbeat at a 1:1 setting. The goal was that as Hays’ status progressed, he would be weaned off the balloon pump.
Over the course of the next day, Hays continued to have low blood pressure, and he experienced an episode of rapid abnormal heartbeat so intense it triggered his implanted defibrillator.
The day after that, Dr. Jack Brand ordered the balloon pump settings to be changed to 1:2, inflating and deflating with every other heartbeat. Longfellow followed through with the orders and adjusted the settings accordingly.
In the hours that followed, Hays was restless and refused pain medication. Cunningham then removed the balloon pump and used a device to apply pressure to the site to control bleeding.
According to the nursing notes, Hays tolerated the procedure fairly well, but he was in a lot of pain.
During the night, Hays went into cardiac arrest. Dr. Shawn French responded to the code call but was unable to resuscitate Hays.
Procedural history: About a year after Hays’ death, his surviving family members filed a wrongful death lawsuit against Singing River as the sole defendant. The family claimed the acts and omissions of Singing River’s employees were responsible for Hays’ death, and that their conduct could be imputed to the hospital.
Singing River timely filed its answer denying liability in November 2018. Within its answer, the hospital addressed the employment status of every medical provider named in the complaint.
Three months later, the hospital propounded written discovery requests, but the family failed to respond for four months. The family also only answered the interrogatories, and not the requests to produce documents.
Singing River sent two good faith letters and several informal requests
for production before the family supplemented its responses in late 2020. The family did not complete the discovery requests until the fall of 2021—over a year and a half after the requests had been initially propounded.
The family also repeatedly scheduled and re-scheduled depositions.
In mid-2022, Singing River filed a motion to dismiss. The attorney for the family contended medical issues and the COVID-19 shutdowns had been to blame for the delays in prosecuting the case. The attorney for the family asked the trial judge to compel the depositions instead of dismissing the case.
Before a hearing could happen, the parties agreed to schedule the deposition of the family members in August 2022.
In December 2022, the trial judge entered a scheduling order setting the case for a bench trial in October 2023. The order set the deadline for the family’s expert designation in February 2023, and the deadline for Singing River one month later. The discovery deadline was set for April 2023.
The day before its expert designation was due, the family filed a motion for additional time, alleging its consulted expert had retired from practice. The family received two 30-day extensions but still failed to designate a new expert.
In August 2023, the judge issued an amended scheduling order pushing the trial date back to October 2024. The amended order gave the family until April 2024 to designate and expert and set June 2024 as the discovery deadline.
Despite the yearlong extension, the family still failed to designate an expert, and Singing River moved for summary judgment.
Instead of filing a response, the attorney for the family filed a motion requesting additional time to designate an expert. The judge granted the extension, and the family then designated Dr. Barry F. Uretsky as its expert.
Several new scheduling orders were then entered, adjusting the parties’ deadlines.
The hospital timely filed its expert designation and after the close of discovery, it again moved for summary judgment.
The trial judge granted the motion.
Analysis: The Mississippi Court of Appeals said that as a community-owned hospital system, Singing River is subject to the Mississippi Tort Claims Act. The MTCA waives sovereign immunity for “political subdivisions from claims for money damages arising out of the torts of . . . their employees while acting within the course and scope of their employment.” This waiver does not extend to the actions or inactions of non-employees or independent contractors.
The court said the question of whether a medical provider is an employee or an independent contractor can be fact-intensive, but here, the family “outright failed to develop any information regarding the employment status of the doctors or other providers who treated Mr. Hays.”
Over the course of the litigation, the court said, only two of the seven medical providers named were hospital employees: Burkes and Longfellow. Singing River provided a sworn affidavit that the other medical providers were independent contractors.
While the family members claimed their subjective belief or understanding provides a conflict with this sworn affidavit, no other evidence was submitted at the summary judgment stage to rebut the employment status of the providers, the court said.
To the extent the family members claimed they should have been allowed more time to develop this matter in discovery, the court said, the discovery period spanned over six years.
The court also said that the family bore the burden of supporting the medical malpractice claim by expert proof showing that any employee of Singing River breached a duty owed to Hays, and that the family’s expert failed to name any hospital employee as breaching the standard of care, which made summary judgment appropriate.
Disposition: Affirmed.
To read the court’s decision, click here.
Leave a Reply