Medical Malpractice Claim Frequency Falls 8.3% as Severity Rises 34.3%
November 19, 2026
byMedical malpractice claim frequency declined 8.3% nationally from 2016 to 2025, while claim severity increased 34.3%, according to a new report from
MyAdvice by MagMutual examining more than 200,000 malpractice claims.
The 2026 Risk Environment Report, released Nov. 18, found that although fewer malpractice claims are being filed, the average financial cost of those claims continues to rise, increasing liability exposure for healthcare providers and insurers.
The report attributes declining claim frequency partly to improvements in patient safety and more selective case screening by plaintiffs' attorneys. Rising severity, meanwhile, reflects changing jury attitudes, increasingly aggressive litigation strategies, inflation and challenges to statutory limits on damages.
"Claims may be less frequent, but rising severity means a single event can have a far greater financial impact," said Mark Poling, chief executive officer of MyAdvice by MagMutual. "Understanding how those trends are changing at both the national and state level is critical for managing risk and making informed coverage decisions."
The report identified neurosurgery as the specialty with the highest liability exposure, with 11.3 claims per 100 providers and an average indemnity payment of $497,000. Other specialties with elevated claim frequency included general surgery, at 8.7 claims per 100 providers; plastic surgery, at 8.4; and vascular surgery, at 8.3.
Geographic differences were also significant. Claim payouts increased sharply in Alaska, Hawaii, Rhode Island, Vermont and Wisconsin, while Nevada, New Mexico, Idaho and Wyoming experienced notable increases in claim frequency over the past decade.
The report's national and state-level frequency and severity analyses rely on paid-claim data reported to the National Practitioner Data Bank. Severity calculations exclude losses exceeding $2 million per claim to limit the influence of unusually large payments. Specialty-level findings are based on MagMutual's own claims experience. Its specialty severity analysis includes claims exceeding $5,000 under policies with limits of at least $1 million, while specialty frequency measures reported liability incidents per 100 insured physicians. Frequency, severity and combined ratio trends were calculated using three-year rolling averages.
Factors Behind Declining Claim Frequency
MagMutual identified several potential explanations for the decline in medical liability claims, including healthcare organizations' investments in patient safety programs, improved care coordination and greater emphasis on communication with patients following adverse outcomes.The report also cited increasingly selective case screening by plaintiffs' attorneys as a significant factor.
Litigating a malpractice case typically costs between $30,000 and $150,000 in expert fees, discovery and trial preparation, according to the report. Those expenses, combined with the relatively low percentage of cases that reach trial, encourage attorneys to concentrate on claims with substantial potential damages.
More than two-thirds of malpractice claims are dismissed, dropped or withdrawn, while fewer than 10% proceed to trial, the report said.
Although spending on legal services advertising exceeded $2.5 billion in 2024, increased advertising has not produced a corresponding increase in malpractice filings. Instead, the report suggests, attorneys are using advertising to identify and select cases with the greatest likelihood of success and financial recovery.
The COVID-19 pandemic also contributed to the declining claim frequency through court closures, postponed trials, reduced elective procedures and temporary liability protections for healthcare professionals. Claims subsequently increased as courts reopened and healthcare utilization recovered.
Rising Severity and Litigation Costs
Despite fewer claims, average malpractice payments have increased steadily over the past decade.The report cited changing litigation strategies and jury attitudes as contributors to larger settlements and verdicts. It notes that while multimillion-dollar verdicts remain relatively rare, their publicity may influence expectations about appropriate compensation in subsequent cases.
Inflation has also increased the cost of medical care, insurer operations and malpractice settlements.
The report identified legislative developments as another source of uncertainty, particularly efforts to reconsider or overturn statutory caps on wrongful death damages. Legal challenges to existing caps can increase potential liability even in states where damage limitations remain in effect.
The authors emphasized informed consent documentation, warning that malpractice cases involving otherwise appropriate medical treatment can become difficult to defend when records of patient consent are incomplete.
Leave a Reply